The Spectator Index – Twitter

March 13, 2019

GDP is not a practical metric for measuring wellness or guiding transitions to better products and services and governments because it doesn’t differentiate between harmful (polluting, causing early death) activities and those creating longer lives and cleaner environments.

There are lots of discussions about replacing GDP and new indexes.

Using GDP to compare countries or with smaller administrative divisions like states or provinces, we see Texas on the same level as Canada, Pennsylvania compares to Saudi Arabia.

Looking at wellness (full health) as the key factor, Pennsylvania is and is not similar to Saudi Arabia. Here are a few points:

  • Life expectancy is five years higher in Pennsylvania.

New Jersey and Taiwan. How do they compare using the High Yield Medallion? Just looking at the first two rays, Wellness and Pollution (tax rates/collected can also be compared)

Interviews in Mexico January 2019

I did one or more interviews each day about economic wellness for two weeks in 3 different states: Michoacan, Jalisco, and Colima.


Photo by Cesar Vladimir Hernandez Sandoval

Interviews ranged from 30-60 minutes and included topics: income source, employment quality, wage growth, cost of living, changes over time, comparison if applicable, to the United States.

Most people interviewed were employees, a few were business owners. I did not interview any healthcare workers or doctors. The interviews were done in Spanish.

Big take away was affordable healthcare and overall security. Striking contrast to comparable interviews in Colorado, California, New York, and Vermont indicate struggle and insecurity.

Image result for gobernador hotel colima
Hotel Colima, Colima

Maria, housekeeper, Colima

Maria works for a 5 star hotel and also a motel. The work is more rapid at the motel, it has more turnover. She lives in the same neighborhood as the 5 star (see above) with her youngest daughter. Maria enjoys swimming, there’s a lush park with a rive and also a public pool.

Maria has 2 grown daughters, both born in the USA and have dual citizenship. One is a doctor, the other an attorney. Most of Maria’s family lives in Arizona, not Mexico. She saves enough from her hotel wages and tips to visit her Arizona family every year and go shopping, mostly for clothes. One of her brothers has been very successful financially, he owns a green taxi company in the San Francisco Bay Area and other businesses. She says she doesn’t envy him nor does the rest of the family because he’s under so much stress all the time. Maria and her daughter have full healthcare.

Take away — lifestyle is important, so is universal healthcare. Middle class in Mexico is rising where USA’s middle class is falling. Few hotel housekeepers in the USA can afford healthcare or annual shopping vacations or pool passes.

Image result for guadalajara taxi
Guadalajara taxis

Alberto, taxi driver, Jalisco

Alberto is married, has 1 child, his wife works in an office. They own their own home and it’s paid for. They purchased a small lot and built it.

Alberto was the most conscious about dangers of driving from the cartels. He chooses routes when outside of Guadalajara with roadblocks and other dangers in mind. He works long hours and makes himself available 24 hours. The January 2019 gas shortage was causing extra work for him, having to spend hours waiting in line at gas stations.

Alberto and his family have healthcare. It’s paid by a small deduction from his wages. His description of having to make appointments several weeks out seemed similar to what a senior on Medicare experiences in the USA.

Image result for santa clara michoacan puruandiro
30 minutes outside of Puruandiro, Michoacan

Juan has a truck repair business. He’s a mechanic and has a few employees. He was raised in an adobe house with a thatched roof, no plumbing. Juan owns a large home with 2 bathrooms, a garden, large living room, large kitchen. He built the house himself with the help of relatives and friends. His business is in a separate building. His wife also works, does administration for an elementary school. Juan describes his house as being “solid” – better than the paper houses in the United States.

Juan’s parents have prospered, they now have a home with electricity, one bath, three bedrooms. Hot water from solar. 3 of his sisters live in the USA. His elderly aunt had heart surgery, it was affordable. Nobody is going bankrupt from medical bills.